MPI TAX

The NextGenerationEU Model and the Struggle for Europe's Future

Munich, 6 October 2026 – Prof. Peter L. Lindseth presents his book “European Integration in the Constitutional Borderlands” at the Max Planck Hub Fiscal and Social State.

The European Union (EU) now finds itself in a liminal space — „constitutional borderlands" — between its traditional role as a prodigious producer of regulatory norms and a nascent, yet incomplete, role that seeks to develop fiscal capacities to achieve its goals. The NextGenerationEU (NGEU) program and the model of governance it initiated is at the heart of this shift.

This thesis was central to the book presentation by Prof. Peter L. Lindseth at the Max Planck Hub Fiscal and Social State in Munich, hosted by the Max Planck Institute for Social Law and Social Policy and the Max Planck Institute for Tax Law and Public Finance.

Peter Lindseth is a legal scholar and historian who teaches at the University of Connecticut School of Law (USA), where he is the Olimpiad S. Ioffe Professor of International and Comparative Law and Director of International Programs. His research and writing focus on European integration and the comparative origins and evolution of governance structures and public law more generally.

Democracy Put to the Test

Lindseth's new book, “European Integration in the Constitutional Borderlands”, co-authored with Päivi Leino-Sandberg (University of Helsinki), provides the first comprehensive analysis of the design, implementation, and evolution of the NGEU model.

In Munich Professor Lindseth reflected on how the NGEU model fits into the history of EMU and what it may portend for the future of integration. The focus was on a critical examination of the model's hidden mechanics, originally established as a response to the pandemic. 

As Prof. Lindseth outlined in his presentation, the NGEU has defined a new model of non-transparent, executive-technocratic governance. His analysis, based on undisclosed EU documents and legal opinions, revealed the pivotal role of EU institutional legal advisers, operating behind closed doors, in facilitating revolutionary reinterpretations of the Treaties that effectively bypassed the democratic process to transform the nature of European governance.

"We observe a shift of power toward executive and subordinate technocratic actors while sidelining parliamentary oversight," said Lindseth. This has not only democratic but also profound distributive consequences. Instead of the production of genuine European public goods, national spending envelopes are often prioritized. While they can be a political necessity, they are not helpful in pursuing overarching European objectives.

From ‘Emergency’ Measures to the New Normal

Particularly significant is the finding that these 'emergency' measures are rapidly becoming the new normal. The core innovations of the NGEU model—national planning, performance-based financing, and enhanced Commission discretion—form central elements of the Commission's proposals for the next Multiannual Financial Framework (2028-2034). Discussing the relevance for the next MFF, Lindseth emphasized that the key problem is not only implementation but legal structure. He noted that debt-financing is an important tool, but debt-overhang places significant constraints on the EU budget and hence must be managed carefully. "Europe needs to grow stronger and more competitive, but how it spends its limited resources is an important part of this objective," he stated. He appealed that the EU should take ownership of EU spending to promote the EU interest.

Lindseth warns that without a return to open democratic politics and constitutional deliberation, the EU's navigation of the borderlands risks eroding legitimacy and creating a fragile system unable to meet future challenges.
 

October 2026